The X-Axis, 2 May 2004
Part 5 of 8: X-STATIX #22

Home | Reviews | X-Statix | Back | Next


 
 

Peter Milligan's other book for the week is X-Statix #22, continuing the bizarrely incongruous Avengers storyline.

Following the template laid down by the Avengers/Defenders War, our heroes pair off into teams to fight one another for parts of Doop's brain in assorted exotic locations.  (Let's be honest, the original wasn't the most sophisticated piece of plotting in the world.)  So it's Captain America versus the Anarchist on a delightfully ethnic beach, and Scarlet Witch versus Dead Girl on a tanker of dangerous chemicals.  ("It can't be dangerous, or they wouldn't let us carry the stuff halfway around the planet!")

Despite what you might expect, this isn't an exercise in mocking the Avengers.  In fact, they're written pretty much straight.  The joke here comes from putting the Avengers and X-Statix side by side, and it wouldn't work if the Avengers weren't allowed to act in character.  If anything, the Anarchist/Cap segment is heavily weighted in favour of Cap, with Tike shaking his little fist and whining irrelevantly about racial discrimination.  Actually, I wouldn't mind seeing Milligan do more with Captain America, though present editorial policies might preclude that.  Cap's reaction to inadvertantly decaptitating a local statue is priceless.

Dead Girl and Scarlet Witch do a fairly straight fight scene in comparison, with Dead Girl coming out on top in a set-up that practically makes it impossible for her to lose.  But hey, that's the advantage of being the title character.  Again, the interplay between the two characters works a lot better than you might think - Milligan gets over the idea that the Avengers don't have any respect for X-Statix while still having them try to act civilly.

This is working rather better than I was expecting.  I'm really starting to enjoy the arc now.

Rating: A-

back | continue


Copyright 2004 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

X-STATIX #22
Marvel Comics
 June 2004
$2.99 US / $4.25 CAN

"The Good and the Famous, part 2 of 5"
Writer: Peter Milligan
Penciller: Mike Allred
Inker: Nick Craine
Letterer: Nate Piekos
Colourist: Laura Allred
Editor: Axel Alonso

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Mike Allred
Nate Piekos