The X-Axis, 2 December 2007
Part 1 of 4: X-MEN #205

Home | Reviews | X-Men | Back | Next


 

 

 

X-Men is the last monthly title to join the "Messiah Complex" crossover, which is now a third of the way through.

And so far, so good, for the most part.  Thirteen chapters is a sprawling amount, but the writers seem to figured out the solution.  They could have written an insanely complicated storyline that actually required thirteen issues.  Instead, they've written a very simple storyline, but dolled it up with enough action sequences and red herrings to make it look more complex than it really is.

Arguably, the plot hasn't advanced a great deal in the first month.  The first part told us that there was a new mutant baby which had disappeared after a fight between the Purifiers and the Marauders, and the rest of the month was largely devoted to the X-Men trying to figure out which group had the kid.  This issue answers that question, with a well-judged twist that reveals that the story has been misdirecting us for the whole month.

So now we know who's got the baby and we can get on with the next stage of the plot.  It may not seem like a huge step forward, but for a weekly schedule, it's just fine.  They've answered the question, and they've swerved the audience without cheating.  Works for me.

In the meantime, they've taken the opportunity to let the X-Men spend a few issues running around fighting bad guys.  It actually makes a change for the X-Men to charge in, beat up some villains, and look effective.  We probably don't see enough of it, given that the team spend most of their time on the back foot.  It's quite nice to see the X-Men actually achieving something for once.

Chris Bachalo returns to provide the art for this storyline.  He wouldn't have been my first choice, for two reasons.  Firstly, the trade paperback is going to read very oddly with rotating chapters by Billy Tan, Scot Eaton, Humberto Ramos and Chris Bachalo.  Secondly, this is mainly an action story, and that's never been Bachalo's forte.  In fairness, his work here is much clearer than it usually is.  His visual storytelling hasn't been so easy to follow in quite a while.  Still, even when he's on form, I don't think this sort of story plays to his strengths.  He's better with stories that are quirkier and more character-driven.  That said, the closing sequence is beautifully drawn.

Another perfectly solid issue.  The crossover is delivering so far.

Rating: B+

back | continue


Copyright 2007 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

X-MEN
(2nd series) #205
Marvel Comics
January 2008
$2.99 US / $3.05 CAN

MESSIAH COMPLEX,
part 5 of 13
Writer: Mike Carey
Pencils: Chris Bachalo
Inker: Tim Townsend
Letterer: Cory Petit
Colourist: Brian Reber
Editor: Nick Lowe