The X-Axis, 2 March 2003
Part 4 of 8: WEAPON X #6

Home | Reviews | Weapon X | Back | Next


 
 

In last week's review of Wolverine, I unaccountably omitted to mention that it was Frank Tieri's final issue on that title.  From here on, it's going to be a string of fill-ins before the blessed relaunch.

In the meantime, however, Tieri's work continues to appear in Weapon X.  And this is all about the level we've come to expect.  Issue #6 is the prelude to the "Underground" storyline, which will bring Nathan Summers into the series as the leader of a group trying to bring down the Weapon X Program.  We get a story in two halves - one is Nathan recruiting followers, and one is the Director being bad.

Nathan's half of the plot isn't desperately promising.  We seem to be back to gun-toting commando Cable.  While I can certainly understand a desire to back off from the commercially disastrous Soldier X, this really does come across as an attempt to sweep it all under the carpet without trying to explain it away.  In fairness, the final few issues of Soldier X are going to segue the character into the Weapon X cast, so perhaps this will be decently addressed there.  Nonetheless, this doesn't have the hallmarks of an interesting take on the character.

Meanwhile, the Director has learned that his wife is going to remarry, so he pops round to her house to intimidate her.  However, he still loves his kids.  This is apparently what passes for his second character dimension.  Sorry, but it's going to take a lot more than that to establish the character as anything other than a psychopath.  Tieri seems to be trying to tell us that the Director is motivated in part by a desire to preserve the planet for his non-mutant children, but this has been a stock motivation for X-Men villains for forty years.

Characters this extreme are very rarely plausible, and Tieri is still not selling me on the Director as anything more than a caricature.  It takes very subtle characterisation to make the mentally ill interesting as central characters, and that sort of writing is not on offer here.

Bad, but no worse than you'd expect by now.

Rating: C

back | continue


Copyright 2003 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

WEAPON X #6
Marvel Comics
April 2003
$2.25 US / $3.75 CAN

"The Underground: Prelude"
Writer: Frank Tieri
Pencils: Keron Grant and Pop Mhan
Inker: Norm Rapmund
Letterer: Paul Tutrone
Colourists: Color Dojo
Assistant editors: Mike Raicht and Nova Ren Suma
Editor: Mike Marts

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Pop Mhan