The X-Axis, 30 January 2005
Part 3 of 6: ULTIMATE X-MEN #55

Home | Reviews | Ultimate X-Men | Back | Next


 
 

Last time in Ultimate X-Men, Brian Vaughan and Stuart Immonen introduced Ultimate Longshot and Ultimate Mojo.  Both characters were drastically overhauled, in a way which made them a much more natural part of the X-Men's world.

This time, Arcade gets the same treatment.  It doesn't work as well.

Arcade is a weird character at the best of times - a Marvel villain from the late seventies who acts more like a refugee from Silver Age DC.  With his absurd 70s-Vegas-meets-disco costume and ridiculous Murderworld props, he was born to fight Adam West.  It is something of a mystery that he instead ended up fighting Wolverine.  He clearly calls for a bit of an overhaul unless you want to play him for laughs - but then, isn't that kind of the point?  Arcade is a completely ridiculous character who shows up very occasionally for some comic relief villainy, to provide a breather from the angst.

What we get here is a half-hearted attempt to give him a video-game theme (almost immediately forgotten about), followed by Arcade as a gun-toting psycho.  Worse yet, Arcade is motivated by a desire for revenge after his sister was killed by mutants.  Motivated?  Since when is Arcade motivated by anything?  He just likes killing things!

Of course, it's the Ultimate universe and the creators have virtually got a blank slate to radically revise existing characters.  It's not that they aren't staying true to Arcade.  But they've taken a memorably goofy gimmick villain and turned him into... another bloke with a gun.  He's just nowhere near as interesting

Fortunately, while this is a disappointing use of Arcade, it doesn't drag the story down.  At least, not if you take it on its own terms, without reference to previous incarnations of the character.  If you look at it that way, it still works just fine as written, with Longshot being hunted by yet another mercenary soldier. 

There's plenty of good stuff with the X-Men squabbling among themselves, and some nice visuals of the Genoshan airport (completely normal and banal, but all the locals are enthralled by the let's-kill-Longshot TV show).  Stuart Immonen really gets across the personalities, and his action sequences are great.

So don't get me wrong, it's still a decent issue.  It's just... not really Arcade, you know?

 Rating: B

back | continue


Copyright 2005 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

ULTIMATE X-MEN #55
Marvel Comics
 March 2005
$2.25 US / $3.25 CAN

THE MOST DANGEROUS GAME,
part 2 of 4
Writer: Brian K Vaughan
Penciller: Stuart Immonen
Inker:
Wade von Grawbadger
Letterer: Chris Eliopoulos
Colourists: Justin Ponsor
and Frank d'Armata
Editor: Ralph Macchio

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Brian K Vaughan
Stuart Immonen
Chris Eliopoulos: Desperate Times
Brian Vaughan interview