The X-Axis, 11 August 2002
Part 4 of 10: SOLDIER X #1

Home | Reviews | Soldier X | Back | Next


 
 

The last of the three relaunched books is Soldier X, the retooled version of Cable.

Darko Macan's first couple of issues on Cable suggested that he was simply going to follow the same general direction established by David Tischmann, albeit with more character focus on Cable himself.  Last month's final issue of Cable took a surprising leap off to the side, and now Soldier X departs the rails completely with some really incredibly odd elements.

Two years have passed since the last issue of Cable.  The story leaves it unclear whether we're meant to take this as one of those six month gaps that are forever happening in the Marvel Universe these days, or whether we're now in an alternate future of some sort.  The opening sequence, a joke about paranoid overreaction to September 11, suggests the former.  Personally, I don't care which is the answer, but it does matter to know - the story is about time travelling soldiers, and in that context I'd like to know whether this is supposed to be the present or the future.

The series isn't turning its back on Marvel continuity, however.  SHIELD are here, albeit in a Keystone Cops form.  Irene Merryweather is reintroduced to the regular cast.  Joe Robertson turns up on loan from the Spider-Man books.  Throw this in with the claim that two years have passed, though, and you end up with something that feels a bit dislocated.  Perhaps that's intentional, although I'd be surprised.

Most of the story follows Irene, who is still trying to track down Cable instead of doing her job as a Daily Bugle reporter.  Her part of the book is the weirdest, as she gets cornered by klutzy SHIELD agents, attacked by lunatics, and finally passed a message from Cable by a transvestite sumo wrestler.  It's at such points that it's impossible to avoid wondering whether Darko Macan has taken leave of his senses.

Meanwhile, Cable is off in a completely detached story of his own.  Casting the Tischmann run aside altogether, Macan steps back to the fundamental problem with Cable - the character's reason to exist was to defeat Apocalypse, and now that that's over, he doesn't have a story any more.  Macan's solution is to make the character's lack of direction the centre of the book, and that's a perfectly sensible approach.

In Egypt, Cable stumbles upon two soldiers who have inexplicably been transported through time, and takes the opportunity to kindly recap the essential parts of his backstory for the benefit of any new readers.  It's quite a nice idea, but it's not immediately apparent that it's heading anywhere, and as a result there's not much dramatic tension about it.  The reintroduction of Blaquesmith at the end of the issue raises some more possibilities, though, since his mentor role is rendered equally invalid by the resolution of Cable's mission.

Kordey seems to be having fun drawing the more eccentric plot points, and I like his version of Irene.  He draws a wonderful sumo wrestling sequence, as well, with a great sense of movement and weight.

I'm not sure quite what to make of this book.  Against my better judgment, I quite like it.  But I suspect I'm going to be in a very small minority.  Bluntly, I anticipate a brutal and swift cancellation within twelve issues.  I cannot for the life of me imagine this finding an audience.  It's just too damned weird, with bizarre shifts from straight dramatic scenes to absurdist comedy coming out of nowhere.  There's a cult audience out there who will like this sort of thing, but something tells me that they're not the sort of people who are prepared to try an issue of Cable, no matter what it's been retitled.

It's certainly a brave attempt to do something different with Cable, but heaven only knows who they expect to read it.

Rating: B

back | continue


Copyright 2002 Paul O'Brien.  All characters and publications   This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

SOLDIER X #1
Marvel Comics
September 2002
$2.99 US / $4.75 CAN

"Dear Irene..."
Writer: Darko Macan
Artist: Igor Kordey
Letterer: Randy Gentile
Colourists: Chris Chuckry
Editor: Andrew Lis

LINKS
Marvel Comics
"All the best names are taken": Soldier X
Deliberate reference or not?: Dear Irene
Sumo wrestling