Reviews
Part 1
Part 3
TOP
MAIL

year in review 2001 - part 2

You're reading the X-Axis Review of the Year 2001. In this part, the second tier books - Brotherhood, Cable, Deadpool, Exiles, Generation X, Mutant X, X-Force and X-Man.

brotherhood #1-7

THE CREATORS: An anonymous writer who will probably choose to stay that way. As for artists, the first storyline was Essad Ribic and Kent Williams, and ever since then it's been whoever's passing.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: The book doesn't seem to have had a regular penciller for issue #4 onwards.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: Mikey Asher discovers he's a mutant and is recruited into the Brotherhood. Meanwhile, in a completely unreleated storyline in England, heiress Malon Reeves also joins the Brotherhood, but they all get swept up in a counter-conspiracy led by a guy called Marshall. Brotherhood leader X responds by trying to incite riots in Philadelphia. Nowhere near as coherent as this paragraph makes it all sound.

The Brotherhood is probably the highest profile flop of the Quesada/ Jemas regime. The book is scheduled to end with issue #9 due to its poor reception - and, though they didn't mention it expressly, catastrophically plunging sales. When the axe hits, Brotherhood will hold the unenviable record for the fastest-cancelled X-book ever, finally beating out poor old Maverick, whose 12-issue run from 1998 had once looked unbeatable.

So what went wrong? In theory, the concept is a pretty good one. A ground-level mutant terrorist group hadn't really been done before, and the idea of doing a book about terrorist movements from the terrorists' perspective was certainly novel. Essad Ribic and Kent Williams were drawing the first arc, which was promising. Bill Sienkiewicz was doing the covers, which was nice.

Oh, and it was written by the mysterious "X." Which was, honest, a Sentry-style PR strategy, and not at all an attempt to avoid putting the name "Howard Mackie" on the book. I don't know for sure whether Mackie was in fact responsible for Brotherhood, but several reasonably plausible sources tell me he was. In fairness, if Mackie was writing Brotherhood, then it represents a quantum leap in quality from the risible Mutant X. However, that still left it falling some way short of good.

The first couple of issues were fairly promising, in that they weren't stunningly good, but weren't terrible either, and this in itself seemed to suggest that it might not be Mackie after all. Unfortunately, the book swiftly settled down to an unimpressive level, and recent issues have had the moments of unintentional comedy that only Mackie seems able to produce. The captive Brotherhood member being tortured on a giant conveyor belt that looked like something out of an Adam West Batman episode was an image that is hard to shake.

It's a shame to see so little being made of such a promising concept, but if this is the book Marvel had in mind, it won't be particularly missed. Brotherhood is not the worst book in the world by any means, but it is nonetheless fairly poor. At least they had the sense to knock it on the head quickly once it became apparent how things were going.

cable #89-100

THE CREATORS: Robert Weinberg, Michael Ryan and Tom Pertzborn up until issue #96. After that, David Tischman writing and Igor Kordey on art.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: Two, both during the Ryan run. But in fairness to Ryan, he's done a lot of work elsewhere this year, including a three-issue Citizen V miniseries.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: The resolution of the Dark Sisterhood storyline; a single issue story about an immortal neanderthal; and Cable goes to Peru to fight the Shining Path.

Cable was the last of the relaunches to take place, by which time most people had forgotten that it was being relaunched at all.

The first half of the year, though, saw Robert Weinberg and Michael Ryan wrapping up their storyline. Weinberg had apparently planned something much longer and more complicated for Cable, including the return of the characters from alternate futures in his first storyline, but instead he sensibly focussed on dealing with the major outstanding plot, the Dark Sisterhood. This still took a fairly hefty chunk of time, though.

Weinberg and Ryan's run had a very loyal audience, although that level of interest doesn't seem to have translated into orders for Weinberg's creator-owned Nightside series. It was a good, solid, well-constructed series, but seemed to never quite cross the line into something truly original. At the end of the day, the Dark Sisterhood storyline was about a secret society plotting to overthrow the government, and the ideas raised weren't breaking new ground. Still, what they did, they did well.

David Tischman and Igor Kordey are a more offbeat proposition. Tischman is best known as Howard Chaykin's co-writer on American Century, a somewhat underwhelming Vertigo title in which a guy with no personality visits areas of the world that the writers find interesting, meets a ton of other characters without much personality who are hard to tell apart from one another, has sex with some of them, and then buggers off home. At least, that was the general pattern up to the point where I gave up reading it. Lots of ambition, little in the way of drama.

Oddly, Cable seems to be more successful, perhaps because Tischman is including a more structured plot here. His version of the Peruvian terrorist group the Shining Path was eminently plausible, helped by some excellent artwork from Igor Kordey. If nothing else, it was nice to see an American comic resisting the usual stereotypes and drawing Lima as a fully functioning city. (During the time this story was coming out, one of the Spider-Man books visited Lima and depicted llamas wandering around outside the airport. This sort of thing is at best patronising, but still comes up far too frequently.)

Tischman and Kordey's storyline wasn't entirely successful - in an attempt to avoid easy answers, Tischman seemed to lapse back into American Century's problem of not clearly resolving anything. The story never provided enough information about Peru to let the reader form any real opinion as to whether or not a Shining Path government would have been an improvement, and so its attempts to strike a note of moral ambiguity weren't entirely successful.

Still, despite its flaws, Tischman's Cable is making an interesting effort to address some unusual and difficult subjects. It isn't quite there yet, but the direction is a promising one.

deadpool #50-61

THE CREATORS: Up to issue #56, Jimmy Palmiotti and Buddy Scalera writing; then, Frank Tieri. Various artists up until issue #54, where Georges Jeanty and Jon Holdredge become the semi-regular artists.

THE FILL-IN ART COUNT: Six.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: The Kid Deadpool two-parter; the killer Catholic schoolgirls Mary & Grace; the Punisher guest stars; Siryn comes to visit; the Weapon X storyline; and the first part of the funeral storyline

Deadpool is officially now back in the X-books fold, perhaps because it's Marvel's fourth lowest selling book and they'd quite like to change that.

The book spent the first half of the year being written by Jimmy Palmiotti and Buddy Scalera, who carried on their direction of rather puerile comedy which had patchy success, but still felt like a pale copy of the original Joe Kelly run. Mind you, doesn't it all? I still wish they'd just axed this book when Kelly left, and allowed it to stand alone.

Anyhow, the Palmiotti/Scalera issues aren't bad, and in fact Scalera's solo effort on the last issue is really quite good, suggesting that he may have some real potential. But they're eminently missable stories.

The big news on this book in 2001, and this gives you an indication of how unexciting the title has been, is that Gail Simone is going to write it next year. Not for another four months, mind you, but that's still enough to persuade us not to write the book off just yet. Simone's comedy column You'll All Be Sorry. was consistently good, and her current Killer Princesses miniseries for Oni is an encouraging sign for next year's run.

In the meantime... we have eight months of filler with Frank Tieri. And in fact, Tieri's stories haven't been that bad, perhaps because his tendency towards excessively violent silliness doesn't seem so out of place on a book which was always fairly silly to begin with. Unfortunately, Tieri's Weapon X storyline falls into his usual trap of not bothering to write an ending. At some point Tieri is really going to have to get the hang of this "ending" thing if he wants to write comics, because it certainly seems to elude him right now.

Could have been a lot worse - but ultimately, just a book biding its time for 2002.

exiles #1-7

THE CREATORS: Judd Winick writing, Mike McKone pencilling and Mark McKenna inking.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: Two.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: The Exiles are formed; they go to the world where Professor X is evil; they revisit the Dark Phoenix Saga; they visit Alpha Flight; and they dream for an issue.

The other completely new launch for 2001 was this rather bizarre book, in which a bunch of characters from alternate realities bounce around other alternate realities generally improving them in accordance with instructions given to them by a glorified bracelet.

The plus points, of course, are excellent art, amusing character interaction from Winick, and the well-judged use of comedy. The minus point is that the very nature of the premise makes the book feel very formulaic. It's essentially the old Quantum Leap gimmick turned into a team book, and makes it very hard for any story to get away from the "Here we are, here is our mission, we have done it, now we must go" formula.

In fairness, Winick has already introduced a variation to the concept in the form of a second group of Exiles with contradictory instructions. Of course, this isn't all that drastically different from the twist that Quantum Leap tried to introduce to spice up their series as well.

A fun book, but it still feels a bit lightweight. 2002 should establish whether the book is going to find away out of the limitations of its formula.

generation x #73-75

THE CREATORS: Brian Wood writing, and (in theory) Steve Pugh on art.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: Two.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: The last half of "Four Days", and the end of the book.

Axing Generation X still seems a strange decision. Of all the X-books, this is surely the one which was genuinely doing something different from all the others.

Now that we've seen the relaunch, a slightly more educated guess can be taken as to the reasons - Morrison wanted to re-open the school and vastly increase the scale, and that wasn't consistent with the Generation X concept. Up to a point that's fair enough, but I'd have thought there was still scope for the book to continue in the new format.

In any event, what he have here is a couple of perfectly acceptable character pieces for Skin and Husk, followed by a final issue which served largely to shut down Generation X and shuffle the characters in place to do something else instead. Sadly, Brian Wood might as well not have bothered, since after he devoted large chunks of his final issue to getting Emma Frost and Chamber packed off to join the X-Men, both Morrison and Casey totally ignored that set-up and wrote stories where the characters joined the X-Men all over again. This is the sort of amateurish incompetence that really gets on my nerves - continuity errors on a scale so glaring that it's hard to imagine how they could possibly have got past unless somebody was asleep at the wheel.

Generation X was doing quite nicely under Brian Wood towards the end of its run, and it's a shame to see it peter out like this.

mutant x #29-32

THE CREATORS: Howard Mackie writing, Ron Lim pencilling, and Andrew Pepoy inking.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: One.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: War with Canada... Dracula rises from the dead and teams with the Beyonder who turns out to be Madelyne Pryor... Captain America as a big glowing loonie... the destruction of the moon... oh god, the pain.

The final few issues of Mutant X are among the worst comics I have ever read. Gloriously liberated from bourgeois concepts of coherence and logic, Howard Mackie's stories were almost surreally inept.

Anyone can write a mediocre story. It takes some kind of anti-genius to write scenes where two people fighting with energy beams on the US-Canadian border inadvertantly blow up the moon, even though they apparently can't penetrate an ice shield two hundred metres down the road. It takes something really quite special to unleash a war between the US and Canada with no explanation, and expect us to take it seriously.

Even at the very end of the series, Mackie was indulging in his old habit of expecting audiences to simply forget about inconvenient plot points. The cliffhanger of issue #31 is Havok being bitten by Dracula, a character who was laughably out of place to start with. Is this ever followed up on? Is it hell.

Even the perfectly competent artists working on this book appeared to be phoning it in, perhaps unable to bear the pain of thinking too closely about what they were being asked to draw. Marvel really should be ashamed of themselves for allowing something this incredibly bad to see print, and then having the nerve to ask people to pay for it. Axing the book a few months early would have been a mercy - and the plot would probably have made more sense without the ending.

I hope it will be a long, long time before I see another comic this abysmal.

x-force #111-122

THE CREATORS: Up to issue #115, Ian Edginton and Jorge Lucas. After that, Peter Milligan and Mike Allred.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: Nil.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: "Rage War"; X-Force get blown up; and a new and weirder group take their place.

Well. What a year.

X-Force was effectively cancelled with issue #115, and a completely different creative team, cast and concept began with issue #116. This isn't entirely unprecedented in the X-books - X-Factor did it in 1991 - but it's still very weird, particularly where everything about the new book seems almost calculated to annoy the existing readers.

Edginton and Lucas' run, the tail-end of Counter-X, collapsed in a mess. While the artwork was nice enough in a European sort of way, Edginton's plot was all over the place, continually folding back on itself in an attempt to assure us that the last revelation hadn't actually been the truth after all, and that what we were now reading was in fact the truth. This sort of device only works in moderation. After several issues in a row of "Ah, but the truth is...", the series just came to look exceptionally silly.

The book was not helped by the decision to position X-Force as the sort of people who go around blowing up skyscrapers on the grounds that the workers inside are legitimate collateral damage. Tediously shock-oriented at the best of times, this story displayed a total lack of understanding of the characters, and should count itself lucky that it was comfortably off the shelves before September 11.

By the time Edginton had finished with this comic, I was cheering the old X-Force to their grave. In fairness to Edginton, he seems to be doing much better on his WildStorm book Establishment, so perhaps his X-Force run was simply misjudged. It was still bad.

Milligan and Allred's new X-Force turned out to be something altogether bizarre. A strange book about a group of media-darling superheroes with no particular interest in helping anyone, which managed to kill off most of its cast in the first issue and kept plugging away at the survivors afterwards, X-Force was something totally new.

In a strange way, dumping this concept into the vacated X-Force title may well have worked in its favour after all. Milligan spent his first few issues bending over backwards to turn us against his cast and persuade us that they were not legitimate superheroes and had no real claim on the name at all. Having them kick out a genuine X-team from their long-running title only served to cement that idea. When the poor beleaguered original X-Force blundered into the book to protest that their name had been stolen, and didn't even merit a complete fight scene to get rid of them, you could tell that Milligan was enjoying winding up the audience. The gleeful letters pages filled with hate mail from people who didn't get the joke were simply hilarious.

But the new book isn't just about shock tactics. Now that the book is settling down to a regular cast, it's working on a more character- driven level as well. Despite the weirdness of their concerns (the Anarchist opposing any other black members of the team because he thinks he'll be killed off once they have another token ethnic minority around), it all seems disturbingly credible. Mike Allred's artwork, which at first seemed to be there to position the team as parody superheroes, has now become effective on a wider level.

New X-Men may be the flagship, but Milligan and Allred's X-Force is my personal favourite of the year. Far more clever and subtle than it appears, this is a classic in the making.

x-man #73-75

THE CREATORS: Steven Grant as writer. Artist Ariel Olivetti left the book with issue #73.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: Two.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR: The end of "Fearful Symmetries", and the death of the lead character.

There were a lot of complaints when this book was announced as getting the axe during the relaunch, but people seem to have largely forgotten about it by now. Personally, I always thought it was a decent title that didn't deserve the level of acclaim it had been getting.

Anyhow, what we have here is the final three issues of this book, from what was undeniably its strongest period. "Fearful Symmetries" was a rather confused affair involving the "brilliant city" at the top of the spiral of alternate worlds, and nuns who had gouged out their own eyes. A strong ending to a rather shaky story, though, since some of the religious themes were genuinely interesting.

Issue #75, a self-contained story which allowed Nate Grey to sacrifice himself and wind up his series, was a reasonable enough affair. The central problem, however, remained Nate's total lack of personality, and that's something the Counter-X run never properly addressed. Consequently, Nate's death didn't mean a great deal to me.

X-Man was a decent enough comic towards the end of its run, but not the world doesn't feel noticeably emptier without it.

TOP
MAIL

In part three, a look back over the year's miniseries, and a quick review of this week's comics.

Reviews