Reviews
03/10/99
17/10/99
TOP
MAIL

10 october 1999

UNCANNY X-MEN #375 - "I Am Not Now, Nor Have I Ever Been..."
by Alan Davis, Terry Kavanagh, Adam Kubert, Batt and Tim Townsend
MR MAJESTIC #1-3 - "Cosmology", "Repeating History" and "Excessive Violence: Viewer Discretion Advised"
by Joe Casey, Brian Holguin, Ed McGuinness and Jason Martin

What's this? No Fast Lane inserts? What a terrible, terrible shame. Without them, I shall surely sink into an pit of opiated depravity and medically hazardous orgies with underage girls. Be it on your heads, Marvel!

Ah well. Comics. There should have been three X-books out this week, but Cable's running late (now there's a surprise), and X-Men: The Hidden Years hasn't shown up either. So that just leaves UNCANNY X-MEN #375. Which is pretty damn good.

We're obviously now in the middle of a pretty major Skrull storyline, as pretty much nobody had guessed before the preview issues were shipped last week. It's good to see that Marvel have finally got out of their habit of blowing all the storylines months in advance. This is the first time in ages we've had the books take a surprise turn which has clearly been worked out well in advance and which wasn't telegraphed half a year away.

The Skrulls, being your typical shape-changing alien invaders, are all about paranoia. Anybody could really be a Skrull, and all that B-movie stuff. So what we have here is pretty much an entire issue of paranoia, as Xavier and his fellow telepaths set about putting their teammates through the wringer in order to find out whether they're for real or not.

Now, if you haven't read the book, you'll probably realise anyway that this is one of those "oh, most of the story was just an illusion" stories. Which are usually supremely annoying because they're so inconsequential. This one isn't, partly because of the way in which the X-Men's various factions are divided up. A couple of very odd choices suggest that Davis may have some interesting ideas about some of these characters - Cyclops and Phoenix are on the faction that DOESN'T trust Xavier?

Needless to say, it all goes a bit apocalyptic, and Adam Kubert's artwork catches the necessary style wonderfully as it steadily topples over into chaos. Unfortunately, the issue is lumbered with some really muddy colouring, and you just wish Marvel would get around to hiring colour seperators of the quality DC have.

Still... revealing that they swapped Wolverine for a different character about five months ago is a heck of a broad stroke, and difficult to pull off well. This issue gets the trick to work, and makes sure that it's easily one of the best anniversary issues we've had in ages.

A

Well, there's nothing new this week that interests me in the slightest (the Superman relaunch didn't make it to Britain for some reason), so instead of picking some piece of drivel and pretending I'm interested, I'll have a look at the first three issues of MR MAJESTIC instead.

I'd been avoiding this series until its recent good reviews, and it's pleasant to report that it deserved them entirely. Writers Casey and Holguin have pretty obviously chosen to play Majestic mainly as a Superman counterpart and to revisit the kinds of deranged, over the top stories that kids liked about the Silver Age Superman. And they've hit the tone exactly, creating something wildly over the top but at no point degenerating into Silver Age tribute. They're aiming this at the kids, not at middle-aged men.

The first three issues are all self-contained single issue stories, with no running subplots at all. This is all about taking one idea and then developing it to absurd extremes over the course of 22 pages. In issue #1, Majestic saves the solar system from an alien invader by... disguising it. Issue #2 is a schoolgirl with temporal blip powers doing ridiculous damage to causality. And issue #3, setting its sights a bit lower, is Majestic going for a night on the town with his rather less uptight colleague Ladytron. Who had some highly unconventional religious beliefs she'd like to share with us.

Obviously all of these are pretty basic ideas in themselves, but the skill is in the execution. Issue #1 realises that if you're going to disguise the solar system, it damn well ought to look like a big and difficult thing. Too many writers these days would just have some cosmic entity or other wave his hand and do it in thirty seconds. Boring. Unimpressive. Dull. It's precisely because of the scale of effort that goes into Majestic's planning and the amount of time taken in showing us how damned difficult this all is that the feat looks impressive.

Issue #3 seems to be aiming at rather different territory than the first two - less of the big scale events, more of the bizarre ideas. The cyborg Ladytron's religious conviction that machines are alive and have rights is turned into a warped and hilarious parody of religious views on abortion, reincarnation and the like. Odd stuff to find in what seems in issue #1 to be intended as a book for kids, but very funny and well worth reading.

Artist Ed McGuinness was last seen in these parts working on Deadpool, before heading off for a frankly ill-advised phase drawing Fighting American and the like. He does a magnificent job here, giving Majestic the necessary sense of, well, majesty while never losing touch with the cartoon element that's needed to make insane stories like these work.

A genuinely excellent first three issues, and a great example of how to make characters like this work.

A+

Also this week:

BLACK PANTHER #12 - Call me a cynical hardened old bastard who's desperately out of touch with his inner child, but was this storyline really crying out for an Adam West-style deathtrap? Doesn't work for me at all, I'm afraid. Still, a decent if perhaps rather formulaic ending (oh look, he's dead, oh hold on, he's alright...)

B

CONTEST OF CHAMPIONS II #4 - Ah, a change of penciller. It's Michael Ryan, who did an excellent rush-job on the Heroes Reborn Avengers and is doing equally good work here. As for the plot... well, there's some fights, and they're not bad fights, and I actually enjoyed the Daredevil/Deadpool one. It's fights. You know.

B

DEATHLOK #3 - Jack Truman gets his body back and hands himself over to Nick Fury. All very well done, but I've got to wonder if this isn't going far too slowly. Three months in and this is as far as we've got? I'm getting itchy here. Looks great, though.

B-

DOMINATION FACTOR: FANTASTIC FOUR #2.3 - A distinct improvement on the first issue, although the formula is already pretty obvious - hero goes into the past with mission, hero encounters complications, cut to next hero. It obviously wants to be a tribute to the joys of the Silver Age, but it still isn't succeeding on what's surely the more important level - telling a decent story.

C

FANTASTIC FOUR #24 - Oh, thank god. At last, a Chris Claremont story that lives up to what we all know he's capable of. After a couple of issues that were moving decidedly in the right direction, this one clicks. The end of the world is coming, and the Fantastic Four haven't got a clue what to do about it. Amazingly angst-free in the circumstances, this is the sort of thing that makes me think that Claremont's return to the X-Men may live up to his original run after all.

A

JUGGERNAUT - Eighth Day, blah blah, crisis, blah blah, eight villains, seven of whom you don't care about, blah blah, absurdly camp script, blah blah, what exactly was the point of all this again?

C

PLANETARY #6 - If the Fantastic Four have all this great Kirbytech, why isn't the Marvel Universe unrecognisable? Well, here's Warren Ellis's answer - because they're all total bastards and they're keeping it to themselves. A great inversion of the age-old nitpick, and a wonderful story.

A+

SLINGERS #12 - Well, that was that. Not too sure about this supernatural stuff as the last storyline, I've got to say - this doesn't strike me as really being what the series is all about. It's an okay story, but really the book peaked about six months ago, I'm afraid.

C+

SPIDER-WOMAN #6 - Still moving gently in the right direction, as Byrne finally seems to realise that Maxwell's omniscience, as previously explained, makes no sense, and gives us a proper explanation that allows us to understand how it works. On the other hand, I still don't care about Mattie in the slightest, and the explanation of the villain's gimmick holds up for about half a second before you start asking the obvious question (look, if we can't see him because he's bending the light around him, then what's casting the shadow?). So still pretty lame, to be honest, with you, but at least up in the realms of the sprained knee rather than the earlier amputated foot.

C

WARLOCK #3 - Which is, can we just emphasise for the sake of clarity, NOT cancelled. (Unless you're reading this five years down the line on the web site, I suppose, in which case, hell, maybe it has been in your strange, futuristic era.) Anyhow, this is a story with the Psi-Cops, used as an opportunity to set up quite what the Psi-Cops are trying to achieve and develop them a little as individual characters. In particular, Psimon is developed as a supporting character, which is nice. As always, Pascual Ferry's deranged artwork brings the book alive.

A

TOP
MAIL

Next week: Generation X continues the Penance storyline. Mutant X has Havok deciding whether to reform the Six. The 1999 Wolverine Annual guest stars Deadpool. And there's the beginning of a new miniseries, X-Men: Phoenix, following what happened to Rachel Summers after she got shoved into the future in Excalibur #75. Plus, Cable and X-Men: The Hidden Years are both running late, so maybe they'll be out next week.

Reviews