The X-Axis, 30 November 2003
Part 3 of 6: NEW X-MEN #149

Home | Reviews | New X-Men | Back | Next


 

 

 

New X-Men #149 is the penultimate chapter of Planet X, and you might well wonder why it's been titled "Phoenix in Darkness" given that she's not actually in it until the final two pages.

Anyhow, Manhattan is still under Magneto's control, and even without the X-Men around to stop him, things are starting to collapse under their own weight.  Magneto's human resources skills - never exactly his strong point - are at a particular low right now considering that he's completely out of his head on drugs.

It's relentlessly dark stuff so far as the art is concerned - complete with the obligatory heavy rain - but Morrison's deadpan jokes give it a twist.  Magneto's increasingly frustrated that the kids listened to him more when he was pretending to be Xorn, who has now started turning up as a hallucinatory personality.  But then, it's hardly surprising that the kids won't listen to him - the more drugs he takes, the more he turns into a two-dimensional Silver Age supervillain.

And as a Silver Age villain, Magneto finds himself totally unequipped to actually rule Manhattan once he's captured it.  As Beak points out, nobody's really in charge at all - and if Magneto thinks he is, he's fooling himself.  Magneto wants to lay the groundwork for his new and rather pointless world, but keeps finding himself sidetracked into arguing about carrots with a humanoid chicken.  It's all going horribly wrong for the poor sod.

Meanwhile, as the genre demands, the heroes (or some of them) finally turn up in preparation for the big showdown.  Okay, Fantomex is back, which is not necessarily a good thing - Morrison may have fallen a little too much in love with that particular character - but this is the right time to be bringing the heroes back into the plot.  All of Morrison's storylines have been deliberately going over the top with their chosen sub-genre, and this one is no exception.

After a slightly rocky start - by his standards, at least - this arc is hitting its stride.  And the end is in sight now, after all.

Rating: A-

back | continue


Copyright 2003 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

NEW X-MEN #149
Marvel Comics
January 2004
$2.25 US / $3.75 CAN

"Planet X, pt. 4 of 5: Phoenix in Darkness"
Writer: Grant Morrison
Penciller: Phil Jimenez
Inker: Andy Lanning
Letterer: Rus Wooton
Colourist: Chris Chuckry
Editor: Mike Marts

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Grant Morrison
Grant Morrison: Crack!Comicks