The X-Axis Review of 2002
Part 4 of 14: NEW X-MEN

Home | Reviews | New X-Men | Back | Next


 

 

 

THE CREATORS: Written by Grant Morrison, with regular artist Frank Quitely.  Yeah, right...

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: A mighty eleven out of fifteen issues.

WHAT HAPPENED IN 2002: The return of Cassandra Nova; a Xorn solo story; the Fantomex storyline; the return to Genosha; a rather out-of-place seeming issue in Afghanistan and Mumbai; and the debut of Kid Omega.

 

The flagship of the X-books, and still the highest seller, Grant Morrison's New X-Men continues to set the agenda that the other X-Men titles follow.  Even Chris Claremont, without getting drawn into the book's storylines, has started to define his spin-off team largely by how they relate to the events of this book.

The big relaunches of titles such as this took place in 2001, and accordingly 2002 has been largely a period of consolidation for the X-books.  New X-Men set out its stall fairly clearly last year, and 2002 has largely been a period of Grant Morrison exploring the new playground that he's established.

The year gets off to a strong start with the conclusion of the Cassandra Nova arc.  The main function of Cassandra was to provide an excuse to drastically shake up the X-books by outing Professor Xavier and expanding the school.  She allows all of these overhauls to be done relatively quickly, without the awkwardness of having Xavier simply wake up one morning and decide to change his entire modus operandi.  Cassandra's defeat, and the return of the real Professor X, completes that transformation, and brings the status quo into line with where Morrison wants to be.

The Fantomex and Weapon Plus arc was a little more questionable.  Morrison may simply have wanted to avoid going into another major shake-up straight on the back of the last one, but this storyline did feel like he was just using the X-Men as a vehicle for ideas he'd been wanting to get around to doing at some point.  Fantomex, a curious cross between Storm Shadow and the French pulp character Fantomas, is an entertaining "one step ahead" antihero, but what he's got to do with the rest of the book, I have absolutely no idea.

The current "Riot at Xavier's" storyline seems to be on the right lines, though.  After giving readers several months to get used to the X-Men's cuddly liberal education policy, and presenting it in an unquestioningly good light, Morrison pulls the rug out and asks whether they're going about things in completely the wrong way.  Some purist Morrison fans tend to argue that New X-Men is diluted Morrison, in comparison to extraordinary torrents of weirdness such as his current Vertigo project The Filth.  This misses the point that Morrison positively wants to work in the mainstream - it's part of his creative agenda - and Morrison exploring themes about youthful rebellion and education in New X-Men is just as important to his work as a whole.

The big drawback this year, however, has been the alarmingly unreliable artwork.  Igor Kordey, an excellent artist, did his career no real favours with some ugly-looking rush jobs at the beginning of the year.  In fact, Kordey has drawn more issues this year than the book's supposed regular artist, Frank Quitely - while drawing every issue of Cable and Soldier X, and the complete Black Widow miniseries on top of it all, inking his own work throughout.  It's pretty amazing that anyone could produce such a vast volume of work, but the end result was still some ropey issues of New X-Men.  Ethan van Sciver and Keron Grant have picked up other issues, with work that's been perfectly okay, but hasn't really enabled the book to develop much of a visual identity.

If they can resolve that problem in 2003, the writing should guarantee another good year.

back | continue


Copyright 2002 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

NEW X-MEN
#121-135

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Grant Morrison
Grant Morrison: Crack!Comicks