The X-Axis, 5 October 2003
Part 2 of 5: NEW MUTANTS #5

Home | Reviews | New Mutants | Back | Next


 
 

New Mutants is still in its recruitment phase.  But it takes a slightly different approach this time round.  All of the existing characters tag along as well, making this the first issue that really reads at all like a team book.

If indeed it's meant to be a team book, which is open to debate.  Thus far it's been written as a comic about a bunch of students who happen all to be at the school.  Of course, given events over in New X-Men, god only knows whether there's still going to be a school in a few issues time.  Conceivably, what we're currently reading is in part an exercise in time killing while the creators wait for New X-Men to sweep aside all of the other unwanted characters.  Time will tell.

Anyhow, this issue's new recruit is Josh Foley, a healer who doesn't realise that he's a mutant and has decided to sign up with one of those anti-mutant militia groups that turn up from time to time.  For some reason, Foley's joined the Reavers, now reinvented as a grass roots thug organisation under the leadership of an evidently down-at-heel Donald Pierce.  Of course, Pierce was the main villain in Marvel Graphic Novel #4 - the original New Mutants' first appearance - and that's presumably a major reason why he's been brought in.  Nonetheless, it's a bit of a stretch.  Frankly, this sort of scheme seems a bit low rent for him.

Regardless, at least it gets the cast out of the house and brings them into conflict with some opposition, and that does help to liven things up.  It's really taken too long to get to this point; however, the characters do work rather better in one another's company.  After all, that's presumably what they were designed for.

With Keron Grant moving on, Mark Robinson takes over to provide fill-in artwork.  He's accompanied by three inkers, which tends to suggest a degree of last-minute panic.  I'm not familiar with Robinson's art; his work here is looser and sketchier than Grant's, but it has a somewhat similar style in the distortions and exaggerations.  He seems more comfortable and relaxed with the book than Grant did, and it's an improvement.

New Mutants still isn't reading like a great comic, but it's moving in the right direction.  It's just taken too long to get to this point.

Rating: B

back | continue


Copyright 2003 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

NEW MUTANTS #5
Marvel Comics
October 2003
$2.25 US / $4.00 CAN

"Not One Of Us"
Writers: Nunzio DeFilippis
and Christina Weir
Penciller: Mark Robinson
Inkers: Aaron Sowd, Wayne Faucher and Scott Elmer
Letterer: Rus Wooton
Colourist: Ian Hannin
Editor: CB Cebulski

Cover: Joshua Middleton

LINKS
Marvel Comics