The X-Axis, 6 October 2002
Part 8 of 9: PUNISHER #16

Home | Reviews | Misc. reviews | Back | Next


 
 

Originally the X-Axis used to cover guest appearances of X-books characters in other books as well.  I stopped doing that because (a) there really weren't all that many of them in the last few years, and (b) they were generally terrible.

But I'll make an exception for Punisher #16, guest starring Wolverine.

Poor old Wolverine.

If you ever read Hitman, you may remember the respect and admiration which the cast of that book showed to Green Lantern when he turned up.  It was great.  Garth Ennis has never exactly been keen on superheroes - this is, after all, the man who wrote Punisher Kills The Marvel Universe.  Superheroes in Garth Ennis stories tend to end up looking very silly.

As Wolverine would have realised, had he done his research before agreeing to go within a mile of this book.

Stupid bastard.

Don't be fooled by the relatively normal cover.  This is a story about a horde of maniacs attacking crimelords at the knee with chainsaws.  Wolverine and the Punisher both set out to investigate.  Except it's the Punisher's book, so guess who comes out looking better?

The first couple of Wolverine pages are relatively straight, and may leave you wondering why the dialogue is so awful.  But it soon becomes obvious that Garth is writing an outright parody of Wolverine, a character who keeps up an endless stream of bizarre tough-guy talk which bears no resemblance to how anyone else on the planet talks at all.  And he never shuts up.  Ever.  Somewhere, now, Ennis' Wolverine is tossing in his sleep, muttering about canuckleheads.

Subsequently, the Punisher gets to fight Wolverine.  The Punisher is an imaginative chap.  And it's his book.  Poor old Wolverine.

To be honest, this isn't the best issue of Ennis' Punisher run - the law of diminishing returns has set in by this point, and it's probably time to draw a line under this joke and move on.  But this book puts the boot into Wolverine so effectively that I just have to draw it to your attention.

This comic hates Wolverine.  Heh.

Rating: A-

back | continue


Copyright 2002 Paul O'Brien.  All characters and publications   This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

PUNISHER #16
Marvel Comics
December 2002
$2.99 US / $4.75 CAN

"Vertical Challenge"
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Darick Robertson
Letterer: Wes Abbott
Colourist: Matt Milla
Editor: Stuart Moore
Cover art: Tim Bradstreet

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Comicraft

Tim Bradstreet