The X-Axis, 20 April 2003
Part 4 of 8: WOLVERINE: X-ISLE #3

Home | Reviews | Miniseries | Back | Next


 
 

Of all the records to get stuck in my brain, why does it have to be "All Over" by Lisa Maffia?

This is a seriously irritating record.  The backing track is one bloody note, repeated jerkily for five sodding minutes.  Over the top, Lisa sings two notes, one of which is the same as the one on the backing track.  And it just goes on and on and on and on with minimal variation until every so often somebody says "And who got the in flow keeping it tight", and it changes chord for one second to go LIIIISSSSAAA (Maffia) before going back to the same frigging riff again.  It's the sort of record that makes you want to drive it from your skull via trepanning.

I am seriously impressed that my spellchecker includes the word "trepanning."

Well, that took up plenty of space that I would otherwise have had to spend on reviewing Wolverine: X-Isle for a third consecutive week, thank god.

Wolverine's still on the island, and the island is still weird.  There's a barmaid who's the only person Wolverine can relate to and who seems to be a stand-in for Amiko.  There's a big hairy monster which is obviously a metaphor for Wolverine himself, because every time he slashes at it with his claws, he gets hurt.

It remains a determinedly oblique puzzle story, and there is nothing much to be said about it that I haven't already said.  Get back to me in a couple of weeks time when all is revealed and I'll let you know whether this is a decent series or not.

Rating: B-

back | continue


Copyright 2003 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

WOLVERINE:
X-ISLE #3
Marvel Comics
June 2003
$2.50 US / $4.00 CAN

"X-Isle, part 3"
Writer: Bruce Jones
Artist: Jorge Lucas
Letterer: Dave Sharpe
Colourist: Oscar Carreno
Assistant editor:
Nova Ren Suma
Associate editor:
Mike Raicht
Editor: Mike Marts

LINKS
Marvel Comics