Okay - it's Monday night, I've been away for the weekend, and I'm tired.  So we're going to skip over some of the less interesting books in favour of the ones that are actually worth writing about.

Chamber is actually one of the better X-books out this week, but for much the same reasons which I gave in last month's review.  Unlike most of the pointless Icons miniseries, this one has a genuine theme - affirmative action - and it's giving us a variety of characters with a reasonable spread of viewpoints on the subject.  It's a pleasant change to hit an Icons miniseries which has something to say, not to mention one which is trying to be more than one-sided.

Brian Vaughan is continuing to develop the whodunnit plot which drives the series, and he's now established an array of suspects without being too obviously formulaic about it.  The bullying Magnetic North faction are a little on the stereotypical side, but for the most part the story keeps its characters suitably rounded.

Jose Villarrubia's colouring seems a little more muted this month, putting the emphasis more on Lee Ferguson and Norm Rapmund's linework.  To be honest, I think issue #1 looked better, or at least more distinctive.  But the story is told well enough, so no complaints.

Orders for this series have been fairly dismal by X-books standards, which is a shame, since it's worth reading.  But then, that's what happens if you keep churning out miniseries that nobody really wants to read - they don't pay any attention to the good ones.

Rating: A-

back | continue