X-Men (second series) #51
April 1996

Home | Indexes | X-Men | Back | Next


 
 

STORY: "Deathbound Train" (19 pages)  Sinister uses a designer virus to turn a train of commuters into "mutants" for his experiments.

What you need to know:
Since last issue, the Dark Beast has abducted the Beast and replaced him on the team.  That happened in X-Men Unlimited vol 1 #10.  Quite how he managed to fool all the X-Men's telepaths, is never really satisfactorily explained.  The Dark Beast is trying to hide from Mr Sinister by posing as one of the X-Men, although you'd have thought this was a needlessly dangerous way of hiding from him. 

Nonetheless, the X-Men haven't twigged, so the Dark Beast trots merrily off to help Gambit and Bishop deal with Sinister's train of mutants.  He's more interested in exploring what's going on than actually helping people, but in fairness to him, he does genuinely assist his "teammates."  And, of course, he duly blunders into the very man he's supposed to be hiding from in the course of his very first mission.  He really hasn't thought this through, has he?

Sinister's virus turns people into mutants, but they go back to normal when they're knocked out.  So the Dark Beast just uses a makeshift anaesthetic on them all.  Frankly, it's all a bit plot-convenient, and even Sinister regards the whole scheme as a waste of his time.

Professor X finally gets Cerebro back up and running.  It was smashed during the fight with the Phalanx in Uncanny X-Men #316.

Scott and Jean visit the Grey family.  Jean catches Scott surreptitiously testing Joey and Gailyn (you know, her late sister's children) for mutant powers.  She isn't impressed that he's taking that sort of interest in them.  Anyhow, they're not showing any particular signs of mutation.

Scott claims to be 25, which is a bit of a stretch.

Professor X phones up Louis St Croix (the ambassador from Uncanny X-Men #305) and asks whether his Mutant Underground cell will be supportive if the X-Men have to take "drastic measures" to stop Graydon Creed from becoming president.  This never goes anywhere; presumably it was setting up a subplot that was abandoned after Mark Waid left.

Reportedly this story was originally going to be called "Hellbound Train", but this was back in the dark days of the Comics Code Authority, and references to Hell were considered highly problematic.

Comments:
Issues #51-56 are the abortive Mark Waid run.  This calls for a little explanation.

In 1996, Mark Waid was a solidly established superhero writer.  His run on Flash had done well.  He'd been getting good reviews for his run on Captain America, which was finally starting to gain sales after years in the doldrums under previous creators.  He'd also just been hired to write Avengers, which had also been languishing.  He seemed an eminently good choice to write the X-Men, and apparently signed up for a six-month trial period. 

It didn't work out.  Waid and Uncanny X-Men writer Scott Lobdell singularly failed to develop a working relationship, to put it mildly.  Waid was relatively polite about this in public.  Lobdell wasn't, and when Waid quit, he told Wizard magazine that "I couldn't be happier."

On top of this, Marvel decided it would be an excellent idea to hand over four of their superhero titles to Jim Lee and Rob Liefeld to reinvent from scratch.  This was Heroes Reborn, an utter disaster on many levels - although to be fair, it did re-restablish the titles as top sellers, so it succeeded in its stated aim.  Waid was unceremoniously kicked off Captain America and Avengers (before his run on the latter title had even really begun).  You can get a real sense of Marvel's lack of internal co-ordination from the house ads around this time, which are proudly pushing all the storylines that were just about to be truncated to make way for Heroes Reborn.  The left hand really didn't know what the right hand was doing.

And as for X-Men?  He got to spend four months working on the Onslaught storyline, which was not only an incoherent, badly planned mess, but existed for the primary purpose of justifying his own firing from Captain America and Avengers.

Waid stuck out his six months and left.  And frankly, who can blame him?

Anyhow.  That leaves us with the Mark Waid run - two issues of actual story, four issues of Onslaught.  This and the next issue are pretty much a conventional superhero story, where a crisis emerges and the X-Men rush off to deal with it.  It mainly serves as a backdrop to set up the Dark Beast as a member of the team.  His imposture was a somewhat interesting idea, but again, never really went anywhere.  He just hung around for a few months before Onslaught exploded the whole situation, without much of a pay-off for his involvement.  Still, he's quite interesting here, and despite all the credibility problems, it almost makes me wish they'd run with this story for a little longer.

Guest art comes from Pascual Ferry, who hasn't really nailed his style at this point.  Of course, it's also a fill-in issue, which always encourages artists to tone it down a bit.  It's a bit floppy and curvy, though, compared to the more angular style he later developed.  It could stand to be a bit tighter, but the story is told well enough.


FEATURE CHARACTERS
Professor X
(last in Wolverine vol 2 #102; next in Uncanny X-Men #333, then in Storm #1, then in issue #53)
Bishop and Gambit (both last in Uncanny X-Men #331)
Cyclops
and Phoenix III (both last in Wolverine vol 2 #101; both next in Uncanny X-Men #333, then in X-Force vol 1 #55, then in Storm #1-2, then in Storm #4, then in Excalibur vol 1 #96; after that, Phoenix appears in issue #53, while Cyclops appears in Uncanny X-Men #334, then in issue #54)
The Beast (behind the scenes; last in X-Men Unlimited vol 1 #10; next in issue #53)

SUPPORTING CHARACTERS
John Grey, Elaine Grey, Gailyn Bailey
and Joey Bailey (all between X-Men vs Brood #1 and X-Man #30)

VILLAINS
Mr Sinister
(last in X-Man #12)
The Dark Beast
(last in Uncanny X-Men #331)
Graydon Creed (between Spectacular Spider-Man vol 2 #237 and Uncanny X-Men #333)

OTHER CHARACTERS
Louis St Croix
(last in Uncanny X-Men #305; no further appearances)

Revised: 9 April 2005

back | next


Copyright 2005 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

X-MEN
(second series) #51
Marvel Comics
April 1996
$1.95 US / $2.75 CAN

Cover by
Andy Kubert (penciller) and Cam Smith (inker)

"Deathbound Train"
Writer: Mark Waid
Penciller: Pascual Ferry
Inkers: John Dell, Mark Morales and Vince Russell
Letterers: Comicraft
Colourist: Marie Javins
Separators: Malibu
Editor: Bob Harras