The X-Axis, 14 March 2004
Part 1 of 7: EMMA FROST #9

Home | Reviews | Emma Frost | Back | Next


 
 

It's another quiet week for the X-books, with only two titles.  In fact, the backlog is starting to pile up generally - New Mutants is still struggling to get back on schedule, Weapon X and Wolverine: The End are both a month behind, and NYX hasn't shipped at all since last December.  I have a nasty feeling that we're heading for a month of rushed books in April as Marvel struggle to clear all this stuff out of the way in preparation for the Reload books in May.

But sticking with the X-books that have actually come out, this ends up by default as Emma Frost week.  We'll come in a bit to Emma's introduction in Ultimate X-Men.  Meanwhile, Emma Frost continues the "Mind Games" storyline, where the pace is starting to flag just a touch.

Previously, Emma had met up with Troy and tried to help him out with his debt repayments.  Last month, they went to a casino and won lots of money at poker through blatant cheating.  This month... well, it's kind of more of the same.  The loan shark points out that Troy's only repaid the principal and still owes another five thousand dollars in interest.  So they go back to the casino, fail to win any money (because Emma can't get into the poker game that night, and mind-reading doesn't help with games of chance) and disaster looms.

All of this is perfectly solid if rather unimaginative plotting, but it's feeling a little stretched.  This is a six issue storyline, and while it isn't the worst offender in terms of gratuitous decompression, the pace is a bit slack.  There are probably wider pacing issues why an entire issue was felt appropriate for this material, but the practical effect that not very much seems to be happening.  Effectively, the story's just spend an issue cancelling out most of what was achieved last month.

Carlo Pagulayan and Dennis Crisostomo largely manage to hold attention with the art.  Pagulayan's version of Emma naturally doesn't bear a great deal of resemblance to the established character, but sells Bollers' take on the character rather well - a somewhat naive figure with increasingly flexible morals who's starting to wish that that clot Troy would shut up and stop blithering so much.

It'll probably read okay in the trade, but the issue is underwhelming on its own.

Rating: B-

back | continue


Copyright 2004 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

EMMA FROST #9
Marvel Comics
May 2004
$2.99 US / $4.25 CAN

"Mind Games, part 3 of 6: Outrageous Fortune"
Writer: Karl Bollers
Penciller: Carlo Pagulayan
Inker: Dennis Crisostomo
Letterer: Cory Petit
Colourist: Pete Pantazis
Editor: Mike Marts

Cover art: Greg Horn

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Carlo Pagulayan interview
Cory Petit
Greg Horn