The X-Axis, 9 September 2002
Part 10 of 10

Home | Reviews | Back | Next


 
 

Also this week...

ALIAS #14 - End of the Rebecca arc, as we get to meet her at last.  Feels a little anticlimactic, with the murder of her father being resolved almost behind the scenes.  Still not bad, but not my favourite issue of this series by a long way.  B

CRUSADES #19 - The end is nigh, and oh god, it's a story about a deluded Sealed Knot member.  This is really not the explanation I had been hoping for, although it does have the merit of minimising the supernatural elements.  Compared with the glacial pace of early issue, this arc seems to have gone into overdrive in an attempt to resolve everything before cancellation next month, and the result is some weirdly forced and undermotivated behaviour from Venus, not to mention what seems to be a chastening plot for Anton Marx viewed on fast forward.  I'm not really buying some of these plot points, I'm afraid.  C+

DOOM PATROL #12 - Oh, I get it - it's a two issue story designed to establish that Robotman doesn't have a soul.  Okay, whatever.  Usual deal here, with attractive if slightly over the top artwork, and acceptable team book content.  B-

PUNISHER #15 - The Punisher beats the living crap out of an annoying journalist for 22 pages.  A bit protracted for what's basically the one joke, and Chuck doesn't come across as quite annoying enough to really deserve the payoff.  It's okay, but I really think the law of diminished returns is kicking in on this book by now.  B-

THOR #54 - Various characters attempt to reconcile Thor with their own religions.  Actually, this isn't too bad - it does make a serious attempt to address some of the standard "why religions don't work" arguments, and since it's really about orthodox religions under challenge, the fact that Marvel Thor is a sanitised version of the real one isn't too much of a problem.  As an atheist, I still can't get all that worked up about these sort of themes ("God doesn't exist" really is a very helpful all-purpose answer that cuts through 99% of these questions), but it's getting back to the sort of themes that made this storyline look promising in the first place.  B+

THUNDERBOLTS #71 - The latest batch of villains turn on SHIELD and complete their hero turns.  The Elite Agents of SHIELD guest star here for no terribly obvious purpose - they don't get much to do that the usual nonentities couldn't have done, and it's not like they're much above that level themselves.  Fairly expected plot developments as the arc moves towards its conclusion.  B

ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN #26 - Spider-Man fights the Green Goblin for an issue... again.  I'm getting overkill here.  And I've never found the character all that interesting to start with, whatever anyone else may think.  Anyway, it's a big fight scene, which isn't really Bendis' strength, and it's the Green Goblin.  A bit bleh, really.  B

VISION #1 - Finally making it to the UK a mere three weeks late.  Always nice to see Ivan Reis in work, so that's a plus point.  This is a rather strange first issue in which the Vision himself barely appears, and instead the story focuses on that old standby, "plucky young boy just moved to a new town."  At least it's not taking the obvious approach, but I'm not immediately engaged.  B

 

You can still read last week's Article 10 at Ninth Art.  Seems to be one of the more popular ones I've written lately.

Next week, New X-Men (yes, really, two issues in consecutive weeks).  X-Treme X-Men is still in an epilogue to the Khan invasion.  And X-Men Unlimited is by Greg Rucka and Darick Robertson, so it should be good.

back | continue


Copyright 2002 Paul O'Brien.  All characters and publications   This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

LINKS
Alias: Brian Bendis
Crusades
: Vertigo
Doom Patrol: DC Comics
Punisher: Marvel Comics
Thor: Marvel Comics
Thunderbolts: Marvel
Ultimate Spider-Man: Brian Bendis
Vision: Geoff Johns