The X-Axis, 1 August 2004
Part 7 of 7

Home | Reviews | Back | Next


 
 

Also this week:

AVENGERS #500 - Er... hmm.  This is the first part of the much-hyped (to put it mildly) "Avengers Disassembled" storyline.  And... well, basically, things go boom, people die, and it's all extremely over the top.  Frankly, despite some well paced moments, it all comes across as very silly, which I'm not sure was the idea.  Remember how Mark Millar and Brian Bendis seemed like a highly unlikely collaboration on Ultimate Fantastic Four?  Well, despite Mark Millar having nothing to do with this, it's basically the sort of trainwreck you'd expect from a Millar/Bendis collaboration.  The plotting of Millar at his least subtle, combined with the stop/start dialogue of Bendis.  The result is a comic that seems to be taking itself slightly too seriously to really go overboard and relish in the camp, but is way too silly to actually take seriously.  Misfire.  C

PLANETARY #20 - At some point I must sit down and re-read the whole of Planetary, but I figure I'll wait until the thing's done.  At this stage, quite honestly, I struggle to remember what the plot is or what was happening last issue.  I suppose I could go and dig out the back issues, but... hell, I'd just have to do it again for issue #21, wouldn't I?  Much better just to wait until it's all finished.  Anyway, this issue has angels, an alien ship and a version of the Thing, and it's actually good fun, even if I've completely lost track of the wider plot.  B+

VENOM VERSUS CARNAGE #1 - Wow.  This is seriously ugly, to the point of being almost unreadable for much of the issue.  Clayton Crain seems to be producing some sort of pseudo-3D computerised art here, and maybe it looked very nice on a glowing computer screen.  But on paper it's dark, murky, and full of excessively swirly renditions of Venom and Carnage that are all but impossible to pick out against the background, one another, or indeed themselves.  Downright unpleasant to look at.  Somewhere in there, Peter Milligan is trying to make some kind of vaguely twisted comment about parenting, but it's not one of his better efforts, and the art is such a slog that it's not worth the hassle.  Avoid.  C-

 

There's a new Article 10 on Monday at Ninth Art.

Next week, Chris Claremont begins his 18-issue monolith X-Men: The End.  (Six issues was enough for the whole Marvel Universe, but the X-Men need eighteen...)  The Fury storyline wraps up in Uncanny X-Men #447.  Magneto turns up in Exiles #50, and Gambit's in Ultimate X-Men #50.  Two more short stories in X-Men Unlimited #4, and the final issue of Wolverine/Punisher.

Plus, if you're buying the trades, there's Emma Frost vol 1 (in digest format), and Ultimate X-Men vol 8 (collecting "New Mutants").

X-Force #1 was originally scheduled for next week as well, but guess what?  It's running late.  What a surprise.

back | continue


Copyright 2004 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

LINKS
Avengers
Marvel Comics
Brian Bendis
Planetary
WildStorm
Warren Ellis
John Cassaday
Venom vs Carnage
Marvel Comics