The X-Axis, 1 April 2007
Part 3 of 3

Home | Reviews | Back | Next


 
 

Also this week...

BATMAN #664 - I'm still not sure quite what to make of Grant Morrison's run on this title.  This is a strange, choppy issue which seems to have absolutely no connection whatsoever between its two halves.  Morrison is often very good with pre-existing characters.  Sometimes he finds a new angle on the premise, as with the X-Men.  Other times, he at least manages to use the concept as a hook for his big, crazy ideas, as with All-Star Superman.  Silver Age pastiche works well with his big, sweeping ideas.  But with Batman, he seems to be almost too much in thrall to the concept, and trying to write it straight.  Yes, he's dusting off the idea of Bruce Wayne as a playboy, but that's not a new idea, it's just one that's been in the deep freeze for a while.  We've got a femme fatale with an alliterative name and a villain who seems to be just a revamp of Bane.  Weird pacing aside, it's done perfectly well, but it seems terribly pedestrian compared to what you'd expect from a Grant Morrison comic.  Surely there's got to be more to it than this?  B-

BLACK PANTHER #26 - Despite a mixed reaction, Marvel have doggedly stuck to their guns on this title.  The latest device to keep it high-profile is to put the Black Panther and Storm into the Fantastic Four for a while, and it's actually a good fit for the characters.  There used to be two major irritants in Black Panther - a obnoxiously gratuitous disregard for continuity, and some very clumsy politics (in which Africans stand around expressing their admiration for Malcolm X, and so forth).  Crossovers and big events normally damage a title, but in this case, it's had the happy and probably unintended side-effect of forcing Hudlin to pay attention to continuity, and dragging the book down from its soapbox.  The running subplot about a suspicious US government looking for tenuous excuses to invade Wakanda remains, but that was always a neat little satirical idea.  Otherwise, the title now finds itself telling more normal superhero stories involving the Negative Zone, and to be honest, it's a lot more fun as a result.  It's also probably a little less distinctive, and I still don't find the Panther's marriage to Storm remotely credible on any level, but I'm certainly enjoying it more than I have in the past.  B+

DAREDEVIL #95 - Goodness, it's an old-fashioned Daredevil story.  One where he's a lawyer in New York, and he fights crime at night, and there's some sort of scheme going on with an established supporting character which he then has to investigate.  Ed Brubaker has devoted the first few months of this run on the title to undoing the effects of Brian Bendis' stories and getting the title back to its classic set-up, and while the journey may have been a little contrived, it's hard to see what option he had if the book was to continue telling stories in the long term.  We've now settled down to a status quo which is identical to Daredevil Classic, except that his identity is an open secret.  Everything comes full circle in this genre, and after to be honest, it's a nice change to get back to basics after so long.  B+

 

There's more from me at If Destroyed, and if you're desperate for more Article 10 columns, you can always hunt through the archives on Ninth Art.

Next week, Chris Claremont finally returns to his regularly scheduled plot in New Excalibur #18, while Wolverine stars in the first Civil War: Fallen Son one-shot.

back | continue


Copyright 2007 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

LINKS
Batman
DC Comics
Grant Morrison
Black Panther
Marvel Comics
Reginald Hudlin
Daredevil
Marvel Comics
Ed Brubaker
Michael Lark