The X-Axis, 25 July 2004
Part 1 of 9: CABLE & DEADPOOL #5

Home | Reviews | Cable & Deadpool | Back | Next


 
 

Six X-books this week, which I might venture to suggest is excessive. 

Then again, if you think this is bad, just wait until October, when Marvel will be shipping ten X-books in one week.  (Before you ask: Cable/Deadpool #8, Gambit #3, Madrox #2, New X-Men #6, Official Handbook: Wolverine 2004, Rogue #4, Sabretooth #2, Uncanny X-Men #451, Wolverine #21 and Wolverine: The End #6.)  When you start seeing shipping lists like that, you have to wonder at what point Marvel adopted an express policy of bludgeoning their franchises into the ground.

Anyhow, first up this week is Cable/Deadpool, which is now up to issue #5 and mercifully free of Rob Liefeld covers.  Mind you, the great one will be back in a couple of weeks for X-Force #1, so don't put the clubs down just yet.

This is an odd little issue.  After taking a fairly leisurely pace to get to this point in the plot, the first half of the issue almost turns into a parody of decompression, as Deadpool spends a large chunk of the book slowly crawling across the floor in what seem suspiciously like repeated panels.  It's a ridiculously silly set-up, but the gag works.

Then the plot goes into breakneck speed as everyone decamps to Singapore for a second stab at launching the all-important Facade virus.  At this point, one of Nicieza's recurrent writing flaws rears its head again - his inexplicable love of overly complicated macguffins which seem like the result of a bastard collaboration between Jack Kirby and Heath Robinson.  It sometimes seems like a Fabian Nicieza character will never simply pop down to the shops to buy some milk when he could use a subcutaneal nanoimplant to send arcanopsychic signals to a hidden icon in a supermarket fridge which will open a bacterial portal through which milk will be telekinetically relocated in hard-light form to a pocket holding dimension located in an occipital interstitiality whence it may be drawn down with the use of an experimental computer program held on three separate computer discs located in Bangkok, St Petersberg and the Sea of Tranquility. 

The macguffin in this story is basically straightforward.  It's the Facade virus.  It will make everyone look alike.  The One World Church think this is a good thing because it'll an important step towards world harmony.  The problem is that it's also very dangerous because it doesn't work properly.  Nice and simple.  Basically, all you need to know up to this point.  Pseudoscientific nonsense, of course, but you can get away with that as long as you don't ask readers to look too closely at the mechanics.

This time round, however, the second Facade Virus test requires readers to accept (and thus, on some level, to comprehend) that the Church plans to convert the virus into lightwaves (?!) which will, in some vaguely defined manner, be distributed around the world by harnessing the powers of Lightmaster.  Quite how that's going to happen is thoroughly unclear, and the idea of transforming a shape-changing virus into an infectious lightwave is borderline incomprehensible to start with.  The "hold on, is that REALLY meant to be the plot" factor somewhat undermines the big reveal in the next panel that Cable had worked it out all along.

And if Lightmaster is going to play a major part in the plot, he should really have been established properly before now - it's not like there hasn't been plenty of space in which to do it.  He's hardly the sort of character you can expect readers to be familiar with.  He's a thoroughly obscure Spider-Man villain who hasn't appeared in twelve years (and that was in a back-up strip in Web of Spider-Man Annual #8).

There's an interesting story in here somewhere.  I like the idea of Cable trying to hijack the scheme for his own social engineering purposes, rather than just stopping it outright.  Kruch is an interesting villain, a cult leader who's manipulating his followers but still has some core of belief in what he's doing.  And Zircher's Udon-style art works well for him.  But the arc could really use some streamlining.

Rating: B-

back | continue


Copyright 2004 Paul O'Brien.  This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

CABLE &
DEADPOOL #5
Marvel Comics
September 2004
$2.99 US / $4.25 CAN

IF LOOKS COULD KILL, part 5 of 6:
"Not That There's Anything Wrong With That"
Writer: Fabian Nicieza
Penciller: Patrick Zircher
Inkers: Rob Ross
and M3TH
Letterer: Cory Petit
Colourists: Shane Law
and Kevin Yan
Editor: Tom Brevoort

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Udon Studios