The X-Axis Review of 2002
Part 1 of 14: AGENT X and DEADPOOL

Home | Reviews | Agent X | Back | Next


 
 

THE CREATORS: Frank Tieri writes Deadpool #62 and co-writes issues #63-64 with Buddy Scalera.  Georges Jeanty pencils issues #62 and #63, and Jim Calafiore pencils issue #64, with assorted inkers.  After that, it's Gail Simone writing and the Udon Studios team on art from Deadpool #65 up.

THE FILL-IN ARTIST COUNT: One - Jim Calafiore on issue #64.

WHAT HAPPENED IN 2002: Parts 2 to 4 of "Funeral for a Freak"; the five-part "Healing Factor" storyline, leading into the relaunch as Agent X; and the six-part "Dead Man's Switch" arc.

 

First up is a title which has gone from borderline intolerable to being one of the books I look forward to most each month.  And to think, all it took is changing the creative team.

As 2002 started, Deadpool was embroiled in the frankly terrible Funeral for a Freak storyline.  The high concept was that Deadpool had died, and come back to life only to find that four versions of him were wandering around New York, representing different sides of his personality.  Basically, it was a parody of DC's "Reign of the Supermen" crossover, because god knows if there's one thing the world was crying out for, it was a pastiche of a mediocre storyline from 1993.

A weak idea to start with, Funeral for a Freak compounded its woes by having no real point to make, featuring a parody of Jackass that strongly suggested the creators had never actually seen the show, and a final chapter where the plot was literally incomprehensible.  Despite having solid artists in the form of Georges Jeanty and Jim Calafiore, the storyline was nonetheless diabolical.

Fortunately, things picked up enormously with Gail Simone and Udon's run.  Thanks to the occasional extra issue along the way, we've actually had twelve issues from them this year, and very entertaining they were too.  Simone came to Deadpool with a reputation as a comedy writer, having worked for Bongo and written the (still unfinished, as far as I can tell) Killer Princesses miniseries for Oni.  Deadpool - and subsequently Agent X - did indeed settle into a niche as the comedy title in the X-books roster, but Simone has demonstrated an ability to balance the jokes against plot and characterisation.

Nonetheless, it's the jokes that tend to stick in the mind most about this book - you just have to love a comic that takes the Rhino and turns him, literally, into a keyring.

The artwork from Udon Studios perhaps verges on the bland at times, and they never seemed to quite get the hang of Deadpool's skin condition.  But they're good solid storytellers, with a neat sense of comic timing, and overall they complemented Simone's stories well.

The relaunch as Agent X seemed like an odd idea given that Simone was only just getting into her stride with the character, and thus far the series still hasn't entirely answered the question of whether Agent X really is the same character as Deadpool.  The story seems to be hinting at an answer a little more complex than yes or no.  Still, Simone has made a good job of the relaunch, quickly establishing a strong supporting cast and a promising direction for the series.

The catch, of course, is that Simone and Udon have only got one issue to go.  The announced replacement writer is Buddy Scalera co-writer of last January's disaster, which does little to inspire confidence.  In fact, Scalera wrote a decent issue of Deadpool in 2001, and chances are he'll produce something passable.  But "passable" will suffer in comparison to an excellent year for the title in 2002.

Most people seem to have mentally written this title off for dead, and it's hard to disagree with them.  With sales not particularly high, and the well-received creative team being replaced by creators with no particularly strong track record or fanbase, the smart money has to be on this title being cancelled by June.

back | continue


Copyright 2002 Paul O'Brien.  All characters and publications   This web site is a work of critical comment and review. All characters and publications referred to, and artwork reproduced, are ™ and © their respective owners.
 

DEADPOOL #62-69
AGENT X #1-6

LINKS
Marvel Comics
Gail Simone: Women in Refrigerators
Gail Simone: You'll All Be Sorry (archives)
Udon Studios
Buddy Scalera